Ten Great Foreign Policy Questions We Won’t Hear in Tonight’s Debate

Stephen Walt of Foreign Policy lists some great debate questions that any would-be president should be thinking about, given that they are of vital interest to both the United States the entire world.  They are the following.

 Mr. President, Governor Romney:

1. You have both pledged to end the war in Afghanistan by 2014. But the Taliban has not been defeated, there are no peace negotiations underway, the Afghan army remains unreliable, attacks on U.S. and NATO forces by Afghan soldiers have been increasing, and the Karzai government is still corrupt and ineffective. Given these realities, was the decision to send nearly 50,000 additional troops to Afghanistan in 2009 a mistake? What could we have done instead, to avoid the current situation?

2. Gentlemen: Neither of you ever served in the U.S. military. Governor Romney, you have five grown sons, and none of them has ever served either. President Obama, you have two daughters, one of whom will be eligible to enlist in four years. Have either of you ever encouraged your children to serve our nation by enlisting in the armed forces? If not, why not?

3Both of you claim to support a “two-state” solution between Israel and the Palestinians. But since the last election, the number of Israeli settlers in the West Bank and East Jerusalem has increased by more than 25,000 and now exceeds half-million people. If continued settlement growth makes a two-state solution impossible, what should United States do? Would you encourage Israel to allow “one-person, one-vote” without regard to religion or ethnicity — as we do here in the United States — or would you support denying Palestinians under Israeli control in Gaza and the West Bank full political rights?

4. Gentlemen: Is the United States doing enough, too little, or too much to address the threat of climate change? If you are the next president, what specific actions will you take to deal with this problem?

(Follow up: Both of you favor increased domestic energy production through new technologies such as hydraulic fracking.  But won’t lower energy prices just encourage greater reliance on fossil fuels and make the climate change problem worse?)

5. Governor Romney, President Obama: Do you agree with former president George W. Bush’s claim that terrorists want to attack America because they “hate our values?” Do you think some terrorists hate us because they angered by what they see as illegitimate U.S. interference in their own countries?

6. Do you believe Japan has a valid claim to the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands? If the current dispute between China and Japan leads to a military confrontation, what would you do?

7. Both of you are men of faith, and your religions both teach that all humans are fallible. If so, then U.S. leaders must have made mistakes in their handling of foreign policy, and maybe even committed acts that were unjustifiable and wrong. Are there any other societies who have valid reason to be angry about what we have done to them? If so, how should we try to make amends?

8. The United States has the world’s strongest conventional forces and no powerful enemies near its shores. It has allies all over the world, and military bases on every continent. Yet the United States also keeps thousands of nuclear weapons at the ready to deter hostile attack.

Iran is much weaker than we are, and it has many rivals near its borders. Many U.S. politicians have called for the overthrow of its government. Three close neighbors have nuclear weapons: Pakistan, India, and Israel. If having nuclear weapons makes sense for the United States, doesn’t it make sense for Iran too? And won’t threatening Iran with an attack just make them want a deterrent even more?

(Follow up: You both believe all options should be “on the table” with Iran, including the use of military force. Would you order an attack on Iran without U.N. Security Council authorization? How would this decision to launch an unprovoked attack be different from Japan’s sneak attack on Pearl Harbor in 1941?

And finally, an individual question for each candidate:

9. Governor Romney, when you visited Great Britain last summer, you were criticized for saying that there were a number of “disconcerting things” about Britain’s management of the Games. Yet the Games turned out to be a splendid success. How did you get this one so wrong?

10. President Obama: if you could go back to 2009 and begin your term over, what one foreign policy decision would you like to take back?

Sadly, it’s unlikely any of these issues will be raised, due the typically vacuous and PR-focused nature of presidential debate. That’s as much the fault of the American people as it is the media spinsters and politicians. After all, how many average citizens take a sincere interest in these topics? How many of them bother to learn anything about them?

Granted, the economy is understandably the central concern on everyone’s mind. But we’ve always been a rather insular society, with negligible cultural penetration from overseas and little interest in what goes on outside our borders (despite the global ubiquity of American culture, and a long history of foreign intervention around the world, the overwhelmingly majority of Americans don’t even have passports).

There are many complex reasons for this psychological and cultural isolation, including the fact that we’re so large a country – both geographically and demographically – that we feel like a world onto ourselves. But ultimately, if our government, often with our tacit or explicit consent, is going to be deeply involved in various foreign affairs, we’ve got the responsibility to at least be informed about it – and to hold our leaders accountable.

One comment on “Ten Great Foreign Policy Questions We Won’t Hear in Tonight’s Debate

  1. Interesting questions, however the debate itself focused primarily on the Middle East. I would have liked to have seen a broader world view. While certainly the Middle East is one of our issues, I personally am tired of the ‘Israel’ question and Nation Building. I would have liked to seen more discussion about some of the global economic issues, global banking and just why especially Mitt Romney believes we have a ‘moral’ imperative to push our culture onto others.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s